Rheolution Article
Are mechanical tests for soft organs comparable?
by Dr. Dimitria Bonizol Camasao
Senior Application Specialist, Rheolution Inc.
Why mechanical properties of organs matter
The month of October was focused on the mechanical characterization of soft organs. The characterization of healthy and diseased tissues is important in the field of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine to establish reference values of important mechanical properties (such as elastic/shear modulus, ultimate strength, ultimate strain) for the development of lab-grown human tissues or alternative biomaterials and therapies. Furthermore, the ex vivo mechanical characterization of treated tissues can give complementary information to standard imaging techniques in the course of in vivo studies of new drugs and technologies.
Why testing soft organs is a challenge
The mechanical characterization of soft tissues, however, is not straightforward. The measurement of their viscoelastic properties on standard mechanical testers, when possible, is often laborious and requires important customization steps (see our previous publication for specific examples). This leads to significant variation in the final method applied and in the properties reported in the literature. In order to illustrate the discrepancy one can find in the literature, the illustration below gathers measured elastic or shear modulus data of porcine lung tissues reported in published studies.
Methods used to measure organ mechanics
As shown in the image, lung tissues have been tested with ultrasound, micro-indentation, cavitation rheology, SAOS rheometry, uniaxial tension, magnetic resonance elastography, and viscoelastic testing of bilayered materials (VeTBiM). These many methods were found in just six studies so this list is still not complete. The range of values reported for the elastic and shear modulus of lung tissues can vary by a factor of 4. Furthermore, elastic modulus should be significantly higher than shear modulus (for example, the Young modulus equals three times the shear modulus) which is not really observed in these studies. It is possible to see that comparison among literature is challenging due to the inherent variations of the applied methods.
Standardization in viscoelastic testing is critical
The lack of a standard method to measure the viscoelastic properties of soft organs impairs the development of the field. The quest for a robust method that can provide consistent data is therefore extremely valuable. Researchers need to know what they should target in terms of mechanical properties during the development of bioengineered tissues, novel biomaterials and therapies. For example, a heart valve implant produced with hard plastic will not perform as a soft and flexible natural valve. If this difference in viscoelastic properties is converted into reliable and standardized numbers, the arrival of these novel technologies into the market will definitely be facilitated.
ElastoSens™ Bio
ElastoSens™ Bio
References
[1] Cui, J., Lee, C. H., Delbos, A., McManus, J. J., & Crosby, A. J. (2011). Cavitation rheology of the eye lens. Soft Matter, 7(17), 7827-7831.
[2] Jansen, L. E., Birch, N. P., Schiffman, J. D., Crosby, A. J., & Peyton, S. R. (2015). Mechanics of intact bone marrow. Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials, 50, 299-307.
[3] Polio, S. R., Kundu, A. N., Dougan, C. E., Birch, N. P., Aurian-Blajeni, D. E., Schiffman, J. D., … & Peyton, S. R. (2018). Cross-platform mechanical characterization of lung tissue. PloS one, 13(10), e0204765.
[4] Mariappan, Y. K., Kolipaka, A., Manduca, A., Hubmayr, R. D., Ehman, R. L., Araoz, P., & McGee, K. P. (2012). Magnetic resonance elastography of the lung parenchyma in an in situ porcine model with a noninvasive mechanical driver: Correlation of shear stiffness with trans‐respiratory system pressures. Magnetic resonance in medicine, 67(1), 210-217.
[5] Hutchens, S. B., & Crosby, A. J. (2014). Soft-solid deformation mechanics at the tip of an embedded needle. Soft Matter, 10(20), 3679-3684.
[6] Rheolution Inc. (2021). Viscoelastic properties of porcine and sheep soft organs.
Related Posts
The peritoneal membrane is a thin, semi-permeable tissue whose mechanical behavior is closely tied to its structure, vascular network, and ability to withstand pressure-driven fluid movement. During normal function or during peritoneal dialysis, the membrane is continuously subjected to osmotic gradients, hydrostatic pressures, and shifts in tissue hydration—each of which reveals aspects of its mechanical performance.
The pericardium plays a central role in modulating how the heart fills, moves, and interacts with its surrounding structures. Its mechanical behavior—defined by properties such as elasticity, stiffness, anisotropy, and resistance to bending—helps maintain the heart’s shape, stabilize its position, and distribute load during every cardiac cycle.
The pancreas is a small but complex organ whose function depends not only on biochemical signaling but also on the physical environment of its tissue. Its mechanical properties—such as stiffness, elasticity, and viscoelasticity—are shaped by the structure of the parenchyma and the extracellular matrix.
The aorta is a highly specialized elastic artery designed to buffer the pulsatile output of the heart and maintain smooth, continuous blood flow throughout the body. Its wall is composed of elastin, collagen, smooth muscle cells, and connective tissue arranged in a layered structure that gives rise to complex mechanical behavior.
The brain’s ability to regulate cognitive, sensory, and motor functions depends not only on its complex network of neurons and signaling pathways but also on the unique mechanical behavior of its tissue. Brain matter is exceptionally soft, heterogeneous, and sensitive to deformation, which makes its mechanical properties central to both normal function and vulnerability to injury.
The spleen is a soft, vascular organ whose structure is closely linked to its roles in blood filtration, immune defense, and hematological balance. Its tissue mechanics—such as stiffness, elasticity, and viscoelasticity—are important markers of both normal physiology and pathological change. Alterations in these properties often mirror systemic conditions, making the spleen an informative window into overall health.